Open Korea

Korean Identities Beyond Borders

K-pop fans don’t take the “artist” label seriously and just use it as a shield to put down the groups that they don’t like even if the members of that group write their own songs.

in ,

Disclaimer: I don’t care if an idol doesn’t write or produce their own lyrics as those two factors are not an easy job to do which is why record labels hires professional songwriters and producers for the job. This post talks about how a lot of K-pop fans use the “artist” label to put down acts they don’t like and how they still use it even if these idols write their own music.

A few days ago, I had made a post asking commenters of what they consider is an artist after I had used the members of Blackpink as examples of writing their own music (solo wise) and yet are not being called artists despite their involvement both songwriting wise (four) and production wise (3/4). Some commenters had stated things like idols creating their own material and being involved in their work. Others had cited that idols are artists as to them singing and dancing is considered an art in their eyes due to the number of emotions idols convey when doing these things. There were a few who had pointed out the double standards of idols being shamed for not writing or producing their own songs compared to influential Western acts which had sparked a discussion of the expectations that idols are faced with especially when they are promoting outside of Asia. In my opinion, K-pop fans don’t take the “artist” label seriously and just use it to put down groups that doesn’t partake in their music compared to their groups in K-pop.

However, it becomes an interesting case of idols not being called “artists” even if they are involved in their music which had caused me to think that a lot of K-pop fans just see the “artist” label as a shield and don’t care if that idol is writing or producing their own music. Also, I think this is more than a hater issue, as there are casual nonfans who don’t consider the members of Blackpink as artists, but I think that has to do more with different expectations due to their status as a group. I think everyone has a right to a preference in a stanning an idol/group that they like and having their view on what an artist is as along you don’t put down idols for not participating in the creation of their songs and their fans for stanning these idols.

submitted by /u/Professional_Set2863
[link] [comments]

Related Posts

Who among male K-pop fans here is a boy group stan? What’s a conversation K-pop fans keep having, but never seem to reach a conclusion on? TEMPEST Takes Center Stage: What Fans Can Expect in 2024-2025!

Latest News from Korea

  • A monk’s purple garden blooms in Mungyeong
    MUNGYEONG, North Gyeongsang Province —Every step along the country road reveals another pale purple flower emerging through the mist. Any visitor soon finds themselves surrounded by thousands upon thousands of blossoms. A wave of flowers winds along the ridges of the wooded hillside, revealing here and there a statue of the Buddha or stately pine trees. It is a truly… Read more: A monk’s purple garden blooms in Mungyeong
  • Transgender performer’s 50 years on nightclub stages come to life in play
    Korean society in the 1970s and 1980s was rife with violence and control masked as institutions and social order. At 16, the world saw her as a boy, but she already knew who she was. At a time when even the term “transgender” did not exist in common parlance, she performed on nightclub stages, singing and dancing in heavy makeup.… Read more: Transgender performer’s 50 years on nightclub stages come to life in play
  • 한국토지주택공사, 매입확약 추가 시행
    수도권 공공택지에서 민간이 건설하는 주택 약 1만8000호에 대해 한국토지주택공사(LH)가 미분양 물량을 직접 사들이는 안전장치를 마련했다.  LH는 민간이 매입한 수도권 공공택지 중 2027년 말까지 착공에 들어가는 필지를 대상으로 미분양 주택 매입확약을 제공한다. 대상 부지는 2027년 말까지 토지 사용이 가능한 수도권 기매각 토지 등으로, 이곳에 들어설 주택 1만8000호가 직접적인 적용 범위에 포함된다. 매입 대상은 민간 사업자가 요청한 전용면적 85㎡ 이하 미분양 주택이다.… Read more: 한국토지주택공사, 매입확약 추가 시행
  • 안윤주, 한화생명 인비테이셔널 초대 챔피언 등극
    아시아 6개국 여자주니어 골프 유망주들이 격돌한 무대에서 한국의 안윤주 선수가 초대 챔피언 타이틀을 거머쥐었다.  한화생명은 지난 6일부터 8일까지 사흘간 경기 안산시 더헤븐CC에서 ‘제1회 한화생명 인비테이셔널 아시아 여자주니어 골프대회’를 개최했다. 대회에는 한국, 베트남, 인도네시아, 태국, 말레이시아, 싱가포르 등 아시아 주요 6개국의 정상급 주니어 선수들이 참가했다. 한화생명 인비테이셔널 아시아 여자주니어 골프대회_시상식 단체사진. 우승의 영예는 최종 합계 11언더파 205타를 기록한 안윤주(경기도골프협회, 만 15세)… Read more: 안윤주, 한화생명 인비테이셔널 초대 챔피언 등극
  • 롯데칠성음료, ‘브레드앤버터’ 100만 병 돌파 한글 패키지 출시
    미국 캘리포니아산 캐주얼 와인 ‘브레드앤버터’가 한국 시장 진출 2년 6개월 만에 누적 판매량 100만 병을 넘어섰다. 롯데칠성음료는 이를 기념해 연말까지 ‘한글 패키지 세트’를 한정 판매하며 브랜드 인지도 굳히기에 나선다. 이번 한글 패키지는 와인 애호가들에게 색다른 즐거움을 제공하기 위해 기획됐다. 제품명인 ‘브레드앤버터’의 한글 표기는 물론, 그 의미를 담은 ‘빵그리고버터’라는 문구를 제품 라벨과 포장 상자에 적용한 것이 특징이다. 특히 소비자가 직접 라벨에 개성을… Read more: 롯데칠성음료, ‘브레드앤버터’ 100만 병 돌파 한글 패키지 출시

Latest Entertainment from Korea

Learn People & History of Korea