Why I’m Disappointed in eFootball After Two Years of Playing the Historic Football Game

Winning Eleven was a memory for me.
In my college days, when classes ended, my friends and I would play a match with the loser buying the meal. It was practically our after-class ritual.
Anyone who loved football games probably has a memory like that.
That’s why “Winning Eleven” was never just a game. It was a culture, something you look back on and say, “There was a time like that.”

After a long time, I happened to pick up eFootball. Even after all those years, the name and the memories were still there.
That’s why I chose eFootball over FIFA.

It’s been two years since I started playing.
My team strength is around 3342.
I’ve bought paid players, and I’ve even built a squad made up entirely of Highlight players. I’ve tried a lot of different ways to play.
Yet I have no desire to tell my friends, “Let’s play this together.”
Because I don’t feel the game has that kind of value.

Japanese dramas of the 1990s were genuinely moving.
They had solid scripts, wonderful performances, and a way of finding the meaning of life in small things.
But these days I don’t watch Japanese dramas anymore.
The format is all the same, but it feels like the soul is gone.
I can’t explain it logically, but eFootball gave me that same feeling.

That’s what playing eFootball feels like.
Compared to the rough and clunky Winning Eleven of the past, the graphics and the technology are far better.
But I don’t feel any affection for it.

Why is that?

I think it’s because the mindset of today’s developers is different from that of the developers back then.
Of course, the premise that a game is made to earn money hasn’t changed, then or now.

Why were Japan’s mini cassette players so popular? Because they were groundbreaking and well made.
It was a kind of craftsmanship.

It’s hard to feel that craftsmanship in this game.
It feels like a Japanese drama that is about to lose its popularity. (Sure, it can still be consumed enough in its home country, but I doubt people in the rest of the world will watch it.)
The people playing now will probably find it hard to develop any cultural nostalgia for it.

It’s subjective, but I’d like to put a few thoughts down.

Before I criticize, I want to set out a few premises.

First, I don’t deny that a game has to turn a profit.
Second, a sports game should be played under fair rules.
Third, I won’t criticize without thinking.

I rarely play PvP. I mostly play AI matches.
The reason is network issues.
I have roughly a 1 Gbps internet connection, but because of network compensation, my players don’t move smoothly.
When I play against someone with a slow connection, their players seem to move far more stupidly than they would against someone with a similar connection speed.
Since it hasn’t improved in two years, I suspect they have no intention of fixing it.
So I only play event matches where I need to earn rewards.
In the recently added weekend event, I used to finish within the top 10,000 and get rewards, but this time I could barely manage two or three wins.

The community discusses all sorts of theories: scripting, network issues, AI issues, and so on.
But the company doesn’t officially acknowledge any of it.
Still, denying it is pointless in today’s world, because AI gathers data and summarizes it for you.
Even AI already holds a negative view of eFootball.

Until recently, I couldn’t quite figure out why.

After the latest update, even AI matches felt off.
The trapping was absurd, and passes were intercepted all the time, unlike before.
In one match, I hit the post five times.
I had come back after a few weeks away, so I wondered whether my skills had declined.
I even struggled in Tier 2 of the AI matches, when I used to always be in Tier 1.
Once I reached 1700 points, I would lose without fail.

Something was clearly off.

A few weeks off doesn’t make your ability disappear entirely.

Then I bought Henry, and suddenly all my players moved better.
The passing, the trapping, the tactical movement all became much quicker and smoother.
That was when I realized.
Skill isn’t what matters in this game.

Honestly, my reason for buying paid players was simple.
I wanted to own those players.
I liked Del Piero, and Maldini, Bergkamp, Gerrard, Lampard, and others.
I wanted to collect them like Pikachu cards.
Even if they had no real value, I just loved those players from my memories.
And of course, I could enjoy playing the game with them too.
But once I experienced my existing players turning into a mess unless I bought the new characters, I lost any desire to keep them.
I figured I should just write off all the money I’d spent.

The moment I thought, “This isn’t a real card, it’s digital, so they can tweak the stats however they like,” the fun of collecting was gone.

It was also the moment I felt the fairness of sports disappear.

The Winning Eleven we remembered was fun because you played on fair rules.
But today’s eFootball adjusts win rates, for example by making the opponent’s AI stronger in the name of balance.
That isn’t fair.

Of course, I understand it.

I know the intention is to keep new users and free-to-play users around longer.

But this company is using a strategy that shows no gratitude whatsoever to the users who buy its products without hesitation.

I don’t want to win by spending a lot of money.
But I didn’t buy paid items in order to beat my opponents, either.

When you actually play, you run into a lot of strange phenomena.

I’m not even given time to pass or dribble, while the opponent somehow gets the pass off just barely as I close in.
Sometimes I can’t win a single aerial ball or loose ball.
And I’m not just talking about online play.
It happens against the AI too.

Before writing this, I played a Tier 2 AI match.
I was up 2-0 early, then conceded a goal in first-half stoppage time (45+2) and another in second-half stoppage time (90+2), and the match ended in a draw.
The AI team’s Bergkamp (speed 87) was shown looking exhausted, yet my defender with 97 speed couldn’t catch him even at full sprint, and I had started chasing from the halfway line.
When I play as Rijkaard, he’s too sluggish to keep up with opponents, but when he shows up on the AI or opponent’s team, he somehow catches even Henry’s pace.

At some point, a thought creeps in: is my skill really my own?
It isn’t only when I lose. Even when I win, I start to feel it may not be the ability I worked hard to build.
My sense of challenge in this game faded away.

It’s like a drama with awkward product placement that breaks your immersion.

Officially, Konami says it doesn’t rig matches, but the Winning Eleven of the past never gave me this feeling at all.
If users are feeling this way now, I think it’s a problem worth looking into.
But they don’t seem interested.

Probably because the money is coming in just fine.

“Winning Eleven” is no longer a game of memories, at least not for me.
It feels like watching a Japanese drama from a time when they were doing so well that they were mass-produced like crazy.
The scripts and acting aren’t good, yet they keep coming. And I no longer watch them.

Most of Japan’s industries went through the same thing.
They were truly thriving once.
But somewhere along the way, they lost their essence.

The dramas, animation, and films of the ’90s, and the various electronics industries, were all like that.
I thought games were the one thing left.
But I now feel that games aren’t far behind.

It feels like a piece of content that can no longer be remembered fondly.

It used to be a game I played for fun, but it has become something I play to kill time.
The legend of “Winning Eleven” that I used to talk about whenever I met old friends has disappeared.

It’s a shame.

Just like the legendary Japanese mini cassette players that vanished.

submitted by /u/Virtual-Object3469
[link] [comments]

Latest News from Korea

  • TXT weathers the storm in ‘Steal The Wind’
    Amid thunderous applause, the five boys of K-pop group TOMORROW X TOGETHER (TXT) emerge from a sea of fog, surrounded by a cloud of smoke and ushered in by pounding drums. Soobin, Yeonjun, Beomgyu, Taehyun and Hueningkai bring you directly to the eye of the storm, as unnerving synths fill your senses. The opening song “Storm Is…” sets the tone… Read more: TXT weathers the storm in ‘Steal The Wind’
  • 롯데건설 ‘청담 르엘’, 조경대상 국가유산청장상 수상
    롯데건설은 서울 강남구 ‘청담 르엘’에 조성한 단지 조경 ‘Nature Drape 청담’으로 2026 대한민국 조경대상에서 국가유산청장상을 수상했다고 15일 밝혔다. 대한민국 조경대상은 국토교통부와 환경조경발전재단이 공동 주최하는 조경 분야 최고 권위의 상이다. 2001년 시작해 올해로 16회차를 맞이했으며 쾌적한 생활환경을 창출하고 국민 삶의 질 향상에 기여한 우수 조경 사례를 발굴해 시상한다. 롯데건설은 지난해 산림청장상을 수상한 데 이어 올해까지 2년 연속 수상 명단에 이름을 올렸다.… Read more: 롯데건설 ‘청담 르엘’, 조경대상 국가유산청장상 수상
  • 풀무원 임직원, 업무용 AI 에이전트 직접 만든다
    풀무원이 임직원이 직접 인공지능(AI) 도구를 개발해 업무 효율을 높이는 ‘AX(AI 전환) 해커톤’을 개최했다.  지난 12일과 13일 양일간 서울 강남구 수서 본사에서 열린 이번 해커톤은 풀무원이 최근 구축한 ‘AX 테크 플랫폼’의 활용을 확대하기 위해 마련됐다. 지난 13일 풀무원 수사 본사에서 열린 ‘AX 해커톤’에서 대상 수상자(오른쪽)가 이우봉 총괄CEO와 기념 촬영하고 있다. 풀무원은 개발 지식이 부족한 비개발 직군 실무자들도 참여할 수 있도록 체계적인… Read more: 풀무원 임직원, 업무용 AI 에이전트 직접 만든다
  • 풀무원, COP31서 ‘지속가능식단’ 성과 발표
    풀무원은 지난 12일(현지시간) 튀르키예 안탈리아에서 열린 ‘제31차 유엔기후변화협약 당사국총회(COP31)’ 한국홍보관에 참여해 지속가능식생활 추진 사례와 성과를 발표했다. 풀무원은 이번 행사에서 지속가능식단의 환경적·영양적 효과를 검증한 연구 결과를 중점적으로 소개했다. 미국영양학회 국제학술대회에서 발표된 해당 연구는 풀무원기술원 구내식당의 식단을 전과정평가(LCA) 방식으로 분석한 결과다. 풀무원 관계자가 지난 12일(현지시간) COP31 한국홍보관에서 생산부터 소비까지 이어지는 지속가능식생활 추진 사례를 발표하고 있다. 분석 결과에 따르면 지속가능식단의 한 끼당 탄소발자국은… Read more: 풀무원, COP31서 ‘지속가능식단’ 성과 발표
  • 쿠팡, ‘가전·디지털 블랙프라이데이’ 개최
    쿠팡은 오는 16일부터 29일까지 인기 가전 및 디지털 기기를 파격적인 특가에 선보이는 ‘가전·디지털 블랙프라이데이’ 기획전을 운영한다. 이번 행사에는 인텔, HP, 쿠첸, TCL 등 대중적인 브랜드부터 뱅앤올룹슨, 포칼, 캠브리지 등 프리미엄 오디오 브랜드까지 참여해 선택의 폭을 넓혔다. 특히 삼성전자의 최신 ‘갤럭시 탭 S12’ 구매 시 카드 할인과 최대 5만 원의 쿠팡캐시 적립 혜택을 제공하며, JBL 음향 기기는 와우회원 전용 쿠폰으로 가격… Read more: 쿠팡, ‘가전·디지털 블랙프라이데이’ 개최

Latest Entertainment from Korea

Learn People & History of Korea