What are your honest thoughts about the Day6 “You Were Beautiful” SBS cover and SM vs HYBE vocals?

The cover was by Sohee (Riize), Huening Kai (TXT), Zhang Hao (ZB1), and Shinyu (TWS). The link to the performance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jlN_fElRHQI

First off, it was completely live and you could tell by both the video itself and the fancams, so that’s a plus for them. However, this post on instiz (which is a k-fans forum) is currently gaining a lot of traction and calling the two HYBE idols not as good at live singing compared to the other two idols, and SM and HYBE stans are just arguing about who’s better and putting each other down.

Watching the actual video, it felt like the first 3 all did pretty well (Shinyu’s a rapper), and yet I see SM stans on twitter hyping up Sohee’s vocals so much and calling the other 3 tone-deaf and bad vocalists when imo he wasn’t the best by a huge gap in the cover, and a lot of people are agreeing with them.

Does anyone else feel like kpop stans assume that an idol just being from SM automatically means they’re better at vocal skills? And vice versa with HYBE? Or did Sohee actually do that much better than the other 3 performing with him? I’m not trained in vocals and don’t know much about judging them (other than what sounds good to me) so there could be something that SM stans are hearing that I’m not

submitted by /u/Appropriate-Cream205
[link] [comments]

Related Posts

Latest News from Korea

Latest Entertainment from Korea

Learn People & History of Korea